Quote:
Originally Posted by ikagan
Reasons for me choosing the G35S:
1. Same acceleration as the G8
2. Amazing handeling - from the cars I drove recently only the RX-8 and the
BMW 335i handle as good.
3. Awesom 5 speed Auto, I wanted the 6sp manual but the cluch sucks!
4. Love the engine/exhaust sound.
5. Much better made interior. (I had a chance to sit in the G8)
6. Great Bose stereo, bluetooth, XM.
7. Infinity is a top rated luxury brand (Yes, I know it's a Nissan...).
8. Got a great lease deal: $410+tax 39mo/12k, only inception to start.
(G35 Journey, Premium and Sport pkg. Msrp $37,200, selling price:$33,800)
It will be more expensive to lease a G8 and the same to buy.
I still love the G8 and I think it's much better looking than the Infiniti plus
the V8 must have more potential for tuning.
|
Your money, your choice, of course.
Sounds like though you sat in one, you did not test drive a G8 GT???
Here is my take – and I have driven several G35s:
1, Acceleration – roughly a draw.
[ C+D test of a M6 G35 shows Quarter = 13.9 @ 103
and their test of the G8 GT shows 13.8 @ 104 ]
BUT
A portion of that acceleration advantage is a result of fairly aggressive gearing.
One result of the final drive gearing chosen ( 3.69:1 - when combined with the five speed automatic vs the G8 GT’s six speed automatic trans. ) is:
G8 GT at 80 MPH in top gear = approx. 2,000 RPM
G35 at 80 = approx. 3,400 RPM
I find that a huge difference – and to me that is a real advantage for the G8.
Personally, on the highway, I would MUCH prefer the low RPM of the G8’s V8.
Though your preference is all that really matters – for you.
2. Handling – I hear kudos everywhere for the G8 GT’s handling \ ride.
I’d call this one close to a draw as well.
3. 5 speed automatic. I’ll take the G8 GT’s 6 speed auto., with a much more ‘relaxed’ cruising gear.
4. Engine \ exhaust. I’ll take the V8’s TQ & sound over any V6 I have ever driven. And that TQ:
G8’s V8 = 385, G35’s V6 = 268.
5. Better made interior. OK.
6. Bose, Bluetooth, XM. 2009 G8’s will reportedly have the BT & XM.
7. Infiniti brand. OK.
8. Great lease deal. Unlikely on a G8 anytime soon . . .
And the G8 is a substantially larger car than the G35.
An advantage to some – disadvantage to others.
EPA G35 A5: 17\24
EPA G8 GT A6: 15\24
So I’ll concede also a likely advantage in stop & slow driving.
Again, your $$s, your choice.
I may buy a 2009 G8 GT.
I will not buy a G35.
Enjoy your G!
- Ray
Just one opinion . . .